Silhouettes – The episode opens with a townsperson (Jaimara Beals) informing Nathan (Paul Zinno) of his sister, Sara Myers’ (Avery Konrad) latest episode. Sara is refusing to stay overnight at the medical clinic. Kristi (Chloe Van Landschoot) pleads with her stay for observation before offering to notify Nathan. Sara tries to convince her to tell Nathan she’s sleeping. Arriving through a back entrance, Boyd Stevens (Harold Perrineau) asks about Sara. She says Sara is okay without an MRI. He questions if it would be possible for someone to have a physical reaction to a mysterious town. Hesitant, she tells him that it is possible before commenting on his shaky hand. She offers to schedule a consultation for tomorrow.
Seeing Nathan approaching, Kristi claims Sara doesn’t want to see him. Boyd says Kristi would like Sara to stay overnight for observation but she doesn’t need added stress. He questions if something else is contributing to her aloofness. Nathan reluctantly agrees.
Matthews’ Residence – Jim Matthews (Eion Bailey) and Tabitha Matthews (Catalina Sandino Moreno) discuss Sara’s condition. He tries to reassure Ethan Matthews (Simon Webster) by saying she is being treated by the same lady. He suggests they play a game to keep their mind busy. He writes “Where are we” on the wall with a marker which shocks Ethan.
Nathan discovers Sara’s bloody dress on the dining table.
Town Hospital – While searching through drawers, Sara discovers several medical instruments that trigger a flashback of events that led to her seizure. Kristi asks if she would like some tea. Sara inquires about her romantic relationship with Kenny (Ricky He). Kristi admits it is complicated before explaining her relationship with Mari who is a girl. Sara credits Nathan for saving her from a bad relationship. She asks if it would be possible to get Mari back even if it meant doing something bad would she do it. Kristi assures her that she would do anything to get her back as long as the others get to go home as well.
Matthews’ Residence – Jim ponders the questions on the wall. Tabitha reminds him that everyone has asked the same questions a thousand times and got the same answers. She says there is one question no one has asked.
Town Hospital – Kristi releases Sara to go home when Nathan arrives. Out of earshot, he bombards her with questions. Instead of answering, she uses the excuse to go to work.
Colony Home – Julie Matthews (Hannah Cheramy) lists the names of people who might notice her family is missing when Fatima (Pegah Ghafooring). After claiming everyone has created a similar list, Fatima questions who is on her list. As she is preparing to leave, Fatima invites her out for some fun. She informs Ellis (Corteon Moore) of Julie’s list before suggesting they introduce her to ‘The Brundles.”
In Town – Jade’s (David Alpay) strange behavior continues. Passing the gas station, he encounters Trudy (Cynthia Jimenez-Hicks) who is flirtatious toward him. She warns him that she would have ridden him like an alabaster dragon had he not chosen the town as a permanent residence.
Police Station – Boyd studies the map when Kenny arrives with his favorite bread bites. He asks him to stick around while he visits his wife’s gravesite.
Makeshift Bar – Jade discovers the makeshift bar. He finds it shocking that everyone is sitting idle. Tom (Reid Price) pours him a “pour man’s potato vodka.” Jade assures him that he will be the only person to figure out the entire paradox which cannot be solved without first understanding it. Tom mentions the “Schrodinger’s cat” theory before saying he is a former philosophy professor at USC.
Matthews’ Residence – Sara has a stolen scalpel and has no intention of going to work. Changing Ethan’s bandage, Tabitha suggests the town has special healing powers. He tells her to add the question to the wall. She admits to wanting no part of it when Sara approaches. Ethan recommends a merry-go-round ride.
Town Parish – Nathan discovers the church empty and Father Khatri (Shaun Majumder) nowhere to be seen.
The Brundles – Ellis, Fatima, and Julie go for a swim. Julie questions how Fatima can pretend everything is or will be okay. Fatima explains a bit about her childhood and her outspoken father. She claims to have seen her father dragged out of their home to be slaughtered.
Matthews’ Home –While Jim ponders over his question-clad wall, Tabitha watches Ethan and Sara enjoy the merry-go-round. Sara tries to lure him away but Tabitha decides to tag along.
Abby Steven’s Gravesite – Boyd talks to his wife, Abby (Lisa Ryder) about his tremors. He suggests his time is ticking down like his father. He admits to considering escaping the town but failure would have serious consequences. He asks for a sign on how to proceed.
Outside The Parish – Father Khatri is enjoying the sun when Nathan approaches to ask about the confession rules. He questions if his confession would remain between the two of them. Father Khatri assures him all confessions would be confidential.
At The Farm – Sara introduces Ethan and Tabitha to the chickens and goats that have names. Sara assures her that living there will become commonplace. She questions what the town was like before the talisman. She informs her of a hiding place inside the barn.
Outside The Parish – Father Khatri chides Nathan for not confessing sooner. Nathan claims it was to protect Sara. Father Khatri promises to keep it confidential but stresses the importance of keeping the residents safe.
At The Farm – After escorting Tabitha to the hidden room, Sara locks her inside and apologizes for what is about to happen.
In Town – Father Khatri orders Nathan to find his sister when Boyd approaches. He asks how to interpret a sign. The bartender informs him of Sara luring Tabitha and Ethan to the farm. Ethan grows concerned when Sara emerges from the barn without his mother. She apologizes for what is going to happen when Nathan approaches. Ethan tries to flee but she catches him. As Nathan approaches, she turns with the scalpel and inadvertently slashes his throat. Ethan kicks her in the shin before fleeing. She tries to help her severely injured brother when Father Khatri arrives. Ethan encounters Ellis, Julie, and Fatima in the woods. Julie tries to console her brother.
At The Farm – Jim races to the farm. Trapped, Tabitha screams for help. It doesn’t take long before the Matthews are reunited. Father Khatri and Sara are nowhere to be found. Kristi tries to save Nathan who is already gone when Father Khatri reappears. Irate, Jim screams at Boyd and Father Khatri. He mocks the town’s nickname, “Mayberry,” and the residents being a big happy family.
Matthews’ Home – Tabitha asks Julie to take Ethan upstairs. She asks for a marker before writing, “Did we survive the crash” on the wall.
Town Diner – Kristi blames herself for Sara killing Nathan. Boyd assures her that it isn’t her fault before reminding her of all the lives she saved. When the radio comes on, he believes it is a sign from his wife to enforce his escape plan. It isn’t just that the radio comes to life, but it is the particular Lyle Lovett, “If I Had A Boat” tune that solidifies the sign.
From Review
Although most of this episode revolved around Sara and her mysterious quest to take out Ethan, it was well. It got trite from time to time but the revelations kept things interesting for the most part.
A solid episode deserving of a 5.5. On top of this, it’s extremely pleasurable to guess each week how the writers and producer will tie the name of the episode in with significant events and characters. Get more From recaps here. Support Reel Mockery by clicking the link. Our onsite advertising is scalable and effective in building online awareness.
